Joab's reaction to the report about Absalom reveals the intense emotions and political dynamics at play during this period of Israel's history. Absalom, having rebelled against his father King David, finds himself in a vulnerable position, caught in a tree during battle. Joab's incredulity that the man did not kill Absalom on the spot reflects the urgency and desperation to end the civil strife. Joab's offer of a reward—a significant amount of silver and a warrior's belt—demonstrates the value placed on eliminating threats to the kingdom's stability.
The situation is further complicated by King David's explicit command to deal gently with Absalom, which the soldier likely remembered. This incident highlights the moral and ethical dilemmas faced by those serving under David. Loyalty to the king and adherence to his wishes are weighed against the practical need to quash a rebellion. Joab's willingness to bypass David's orders for the sake of political expediency presents a stark contrast to the soldier's restraint, emphasizing the varied responses to authority and justice within the narrative.